Re: STORY WORKSHOP 2021 | EPISODE 02, SEASON 2
Reply #11 –
First thoughts off of my head:
1. The enemy is...not really something that can be conventionally fought. there's no reliable way to prevent possession, there is no apparent internal division, and there's no cure (yet) which means the only way to control the infection is expensive and can't be relied upon too much. the ONLY upside is it seems it can only get meat puppets occasionally/at a limited rate. So there is a hard cap on just how many infected there can be, which can be calculated if we can figure out the infection rate, how it spreads, and how long it's been active.
2. as such, any immediate efforts to deal with the problem are basically futile long term, but can buy time to figure out (a) what this thing is (b) how it thinks (c) how to cure the infected and (d) how to permakill or seal it away. Whatever it is has a number of logical flaws in its ideology (chief among them: wiping out life, which increases entropy as part of its existence, to increase entropy in the universe, a goal that is inevitable and pointless to accelerate as far as we're concerned) and has made plans that can be foiled with reasonably low casualties by people who are competent and thinking on their feet, which means it does have a mind that can, to some degree, be understood; it's human enough to be wrong and make mistakes, basically. But you need the first 3 items, I believe, to be sure of (d).
All of this is going to be really hard to attain at present. The political situation is, I believe, the more pressing matter in the short term for reasons outlined above. Civilian government is, apparently, not infected, which means the enemy made a pretty big mistake; Starfleet is pretty thoroughly subordinated to the civilian government, and historically coup attempts and mutiny, when they do occur, are dealt with swiftly and the status quo reestablished, which means there's never been major popular support for the military overstepping its bounds, even at the height of Founder paranoia.
So basically, getting the President a list of infected, with proof, is the key. The enemy cannot, as far as we know, infect sufficient people at sufficient speed to control a significant portion of the fleet. So a decap strike and the sequestering of infected officers is not just possible, but a short term major victory against the enemy. The likelihood of anything more than failure to sequester every last infected officer is low, and while there is a pretty good chance there is an infected agent keeping an eye on the President, we have technology that we know works on them.
It would, I believe, help if we had a quality cloaking device.
tl;dr:
1. Victory possible in theory, currently practically impossible.
2. Short term win to buy us time for working out the kinks of 1. entirely possible and requiring only some careful planning to cover major loose ends and avoid "somebody posted the wrong status update to the wrong Facebook" kinds of stupid SNAFUs.
3. A good cloaking device would make all our lives much easier.